Auction Values for All Four ottoneu Formats

Auction season is nearly upon us, which means many of you are scouring the web to find your draft projections, auction values, sleepers, and more. And, scour as you might, you are not finding anything that even closely resembles ottoneu auction values.

But we here at RotoGraphs are nothing if not obliging and so, for the second year, I am going to present you with auction values for all ottoneu formats.

If you compare this year’s article to last year’s version you’ll notice a change in the title — three has turned to four. This is not because of anything new in ottoneu, but because of a realization I made. Last year, I assumed that FanGraphs Points and SABR Points would have similar values. But after spending some time with both formats, it is pretty clear they don’t. We’ll see that in action later, but for now, just know that I have you fully covered this year — 4×4, 5×5, FG Points and SABR Points!

There is another change, though. Last year, I provided both first year and “inflated” auction values. 2013 was the first time I explored inflation in depth and part of my goal was to improve my inflation calculation prior to the 2014 season. Instead, what I found was that the inflated numbers just don’t make logical sense, except in a specific context.

For example, in the original ottoneu league, here is the list of first basemen who are free agents: Prince Fielder, Eric Hosmer, Billy Butler, Adrian Gonzalez, and bunch of guys who are not worth mentioning. So you have a stud (and in 4×4, Prince is a beast), a guy with potential, a guy with power questions, and a guy maybe past his prime. But I count at least four teams with questions at 1B and there are a number of others that need to fill their util slot.

So, if I had to guess, the bidding on Fielder in that league will easily cross $50 and probably end up closer to $60. Does it make sense, therefore, to tell you that Fielder’s value is inflated to $60? On the other hand, I have both Ryan Zimmerman and Kyle Seager in that league and just traded for David Ortiz. So Fielder is not worth close to $60 (or even $50) to me. Basically, the lesson I found last year is that inflation varies greatly from league to league – far more than typical auction values. If your league undervalues 1B and pays them below market in year one, you may see some fluctuation in auction prices compared to other leagues that year, but in year two – and three and four and… – that compounds and the variations grow. The values below are still good as guideposts for a league in ANY season, but rather than basically give you projected inflated values for one particular situation, I’d just advise you to be expect at least 10-20% inflation on average and to look closely at your league – both available free agents and team needs – to see what players will be inflated 40% and what players won’t see much inflation at all.

Before we dive into the charts, I also want to look at how the different formats compare to each other, as well as some interesting data on how salaries work in each format. Let’s start with the hitters.

Yr1HitterValues

It’s a little hard to see what is going on there, but a few quick call outs. First, Notice that the SABR Points values have the highest peak but drop down very quickly and end up aligned with FanGraphs Points by the end. This is in large part because of the way pitchers are valued. Pitchers create far less value in SABR leagues than FG leagues, which means that you should allocate more money in those leagues to hitters.

5×5 leagues have the biggest spread of values, followed by 4×4 – a result of the fact that those leagues require balance. The guy with the most value in a points league (it’s Miguel Cabrera, in both cases) doesn’t get hurt by creating value without speed and all-around studs (like Mike Trout) get no extra value for providing “five-category” production, since we don’t care about categories in points leagues. As a result, a lot of three-to-four category studs are far more valuable in points leagues, while a lot of one-to-two category guys are far less valuable.

As for the pitchers:

Yr1PitcherValues

In this case, SABR points is again the highest peak, but only barely – two other formats (FG Pts and 4×4) are within $1.60 of the SABR peak) – and it’s drop is more precipitous, falling below FanGraphs points by quite a bit. You’ll notice that 5×5 drops off VERY fast – this is a result of huge value drops from RP not projected to accrue saves. If you aren’t closing, you better be starting.

And one last set of charts, before the values. Here are four graphs, looking at hitter and pitcher values for each format.

4×4
4x4

5×5
5x5

FanGraphs Pts
FGP

SABR Pts
SABR

So what can we see here? First of all, the 5×5 graph stands out as unique, with huge separation between pitchers and hitters. This certainly validates the “don’t spend on pitching” approach that so many experts take and advocate, particularly considering the traditional 5×5 format is where that theory was born.

Interestingly, both roto leagues show a pattern where the gap between pitchers and hitters grows as the prices get cheaper (so the 10th pitcher is closer in value to the 10th hitter than the 100th pitcher is to the 100th hitter) while both points leagues show the opposite pattern – the 150th pitcher is about as valuable as the 150th hitter in those leagues, but at the top, the gap is huge.

You can also see here the difference between SABR and FanGraphs points that I mentioned earlier – the FanGraphs Points pitchers “catch up” with hitter values by about the 75th pitcher/hitter taken, while in SABR leagues, that breakeven point comes closer to the 160th pitcher/hitter taken.

With that, let’s get to the reason you are all here. Below are two tables – one for hitters and one for pitchers – each of which shows a player, the position consider their “primary” position (basically the weakest position they qualify at), their Year One price in all formats.

A few quick reminders — 1) this is value for 2014, not beyond. So prospects are going to look cheap here, and we are not going to make Mike Trout more expensive because of his potential value in 2015 and beyond. 2) If you are in the second year of your league or beyond, use these values as a guidepost. Inflation will be anywhere from10-40% higher than the values you see here depending on the exact players available in your restocking draft. 3) I created these values using unedited Steamer projections. What that means is that some values you disagree with may be a result of Steamer projecting a player worse (or better) than you expect.

Hitters

Name Pos 4×4 5×5 FG Pts SABR Pts
Miguel Cabrera 3B $58.77 $47.11 $70.77 $81.03
Mike Trout OF $53.32 $50.27 $63.43 $72.62
Buster Posey C $38.78 $40.17 $57.39 $65.71
Joe Mauer C $30.81 $32.06 $49.65 $56.85
Troy Tulowitzki SS $46.35 $41.43 $47.63 $54.54
Paul Goldschmidt 1B $34.15 $34.27 $44.40 $50.84
Andrew McCutchen OF $35.81 $33.41 $40.98 $46.92
Giancarlo Stanton OF $42.20 $27.49 $40.13 $45.95
Carlos Santana C $28.95 $25.59 $38.68 $44.29
Carlos Gonzalez OF $36.59 $35.64 $37.73 $43.21
Robinson Cano 2B $36.37 $33.67 $37.56 $43.01
Joey Votto 1B $30.58 $20.63 $36.89 $42.24
Edwin Encarnacion 3B $33.15 $27.45 $35.18 $40.28
Shin-Soo Choo OF $32.42 $25.43 $35.08 $40.17
Jose Bautista OF $37.87 $25.46 $32.70 $37.44
Prince Fielder 1B $26.31 $23.95 $31.20 $35.73
Ryan Braun OF $29.13 $26.78 $30.02 $34.37
Yasiel Puig OF $29.25 $30.95 $29.99 $34.33
Adrian Beltre 3B $25.54 $27.55 $29.41 $33.67
Evan Longoria 3B $26.70 $20.96 $29.21 $33.45
Anthony Rizzo 1B $22.61 $24.01 $29.19 $33.42
Matt Holliday OF $29.52 $22.72 $29.04 $33.25
Wilin Rosario C $27.48 $33.65 $28.41 $32.53
Pablo Sandoval 3B $20.87 $20.09 $26.89 $30.79
Brian McCann C $25.00 $26.77 $26.69 $30.56
Ian Kinsler 2B $27.06 $30.31 $26.38 $30.21
Hanley Ramirez SS $26.75 $29.53 $25.76 $29.49
Albert Pujols 1B $23.61 $25.58 $25.56 $29.27
Miguel Montero C $17.55 $19.34 $25.32 $28.99
Alex Gordon OF $22.38 $20.96 $24.90 $28.51
Chris Davis 1B $24.49 $24.33 $24.35 $27.88
David Wright 3B $20.99 $19.27 $24.35 $27.88
Adrian Gonzalez 1B $16.69 $21.80 $24.32 $27.85
David Ortiz 1B $20.07 $17.43 $23.40 $26.79
Jason Castro C $16.54 $19.41 $23.37 $26.76
Jose Reyes SS $21.68 $32.54 $23.28 $26.65
Aaron Hill 2B $24.22 $26.02 $22.92 $26.24
Billy Butler 1B $15.80 $19.00 $22.90 $26.22
Freddie Freeman 1B $19.27 $17.93 $22.63 $25.91
Justin Upton OF $24.94 $17.58 $22.14 $25.35
Jason Heyward OF $27.61 $19.47 $21.98 $25.16
Dustin Pedroia 2B $23.91 $26.25 $21.42 $24.52
Nick Swisher OF $23.14 $16.12 $21.31 $24.40
Salvador Perez C $17.17 $25.91 $21.30 $24.39
Allen Craig OF $21.75 $19.91 $20.88 $23.91
Eric Hosmer 1B $12.66 $23.17 $20.84 $23.87
Bryce Harper OF $23.08 $17.89 $20.03 $22.93
Martin Prado 2B $24.46 $26.74 $26.90 $20.38
Jay Bruce OF $22.60 $17.07 $17.71 $20.28
Adam Jones OF $20.59 $26.09 $17.69 $20.25
Jason Kipnis 2B $22.32 $26.40 $17.55 $20.09
Ben Zobrist SS $22.81 $22.12 $20.73 $19.68
Michael Cuddyer OF $19.80 $19.75 $17.12 $19.60
Hunter Pence OF $17.23 $20.44 $16.18 $18.52
Jacoby Ellsbury OF $12.45 $26.81 $15.97 $18.28
Kendrys Morales 1B $11.35 $17.62 $15.64 $17.91
Michael Morse OF $18.67 $19.42 $15.54 $17.79
Jose Altuve 2B $14.59 $30.56 $15.34 $17.56
Josh Willingham OF $19.85 $11.29 $15.32 $17.55
Matt Kemp OF $18.71 $18.60 $15.28 $17.50
Carlos Beltran OF $17.21 $13.49 $15.10 $17.29
Domonic Brown OF $17.22 $16.57 $14.76 $16.90
Chase Utley 2B $18.84 $15.93 $14.36 $16.44
Austin Jackson OF $15.30 $15.63 $13.83 $15.84
Dexter Fowler OF $18.57 $13.50 $13.72 $15.71
Elvis Andrus SS $11.32 $27.15 $13.56 $15.52
Jayson Werth OF $13.93 $6.61 $13.45 $15.40
J.J. Hardy SS $17.77 $22.76 $13.40 $15.34
Nelson Cruz OF $16.92 $14.12 $12.93 $14.81
Everth Cabrera SS $7.15 $28.06 $12.81 $14.66
Josh Hamilton OF $18.88 $17.97 $12.46 $14.26
Matt Carpenter 2B $22.08 $16.37 $21.06 $14.24
Starlin Castro SS $13.94 $22.63 $12.30 $14.09
Neil Walker 2B $15.06 $10.56 $12.25 $14.02
Ryan Zimmerman 3B $11.65 $8.25 $12.09 $13.85
Chris Carter OF $20.13 $12.16 $12.01 $13.76
Josh Donaldson 3B $13.12 $11.71 $11.30 $12.94
Ian Desmond SS $13.96 $20.77 $11.03 $12.63
Matt Wieters C $14.39 $16.94 $10.59 $12.12
Wil Myers OF $16.95 $16.23 $10.56 $12.10
Aramis Ramirez 3B $9.30 $6.47 $10.52 $12.04
Mark Trumbo OF $16.55 $15.19 $10.39 $11.89
Brandon Belt 1B $2.87 $4.27 $10.03 $11.48
Yoenis Cespedes OF $14.04 $13.89 $9.81 $11.23
Carlos Gomez OF $11.18 $23.12 $9.79 $11.21
Brett Lawrie 2B $24.73 $27.04 $18.64 $10.92
Josh Rutledge SS $10.94 $9.02 $11.43 $10.62
Kole Calhoun OF $10.20 $8.79 $8.98 $10.28
Adam Eaton OF $10.38 $15.95 $8.88 $10.17
Jean Segura SS $8.55 $24.11 $8.87 $10.15
Carlos Quentin OF $12.44 $3.51 $8.79 $10.06
Matt Joyce OF $12.51 $6.37 $8.63 $9.88
Torii Hunter OF $13.04 $15.59 $8.28 $9.48
Corey Dickerson OF $2.83 $- $8.17 $9.36
Pedro Alvarez 3B $12.44 $8.40 $8.16 $9.34
Oswaldo Arcia OF $12.70 $11.82 $7.57 $8.67
Nick Markakis OF $10.77 $9.91 $7.31 $8.37
Asdrubal Cabrera SS $10.77 $13.55 $7.22 $8.27
Brad Miller SS $14.29 $18.86 $10.55 $8.26
Jed Lowrie SS $14.12 $13.29 $10.16 $8.06
Matt Adams 1B $6.01 $11.10 $6.98 $7.99
Brandon Moss OF $8.29 $0.91 $6.97 $7.98
Howie Kendrick 2B $11.85 $17.88 $6.69 $7.66
Mark Teixeira 1B $4.48 $2.46 $6.67 $7.63
Cody Ross OF $9.41 $7.76 $6.53 $7.47
Colby Rasmus OF $12.89 $7.57 $6.52 $7.47
Andre Ethier OF $5.14 $- $6.35 $7.27
Andrelton Simmons SS $10.06 $15.27 $6.30 $7.21
Chase Headley 3B $4.91 $5.28 $6.24 $7.14
Erick Aybar SS $9.32 $22.48 $6.22 $7.13
Starling Marte OF $7.18 $14.25 $6.14 $7.03
Mike Napoli 1B $2.48 $- $6.03 $6.91
Jhonny Peralta SS $9.05 $10.57 $5.88 $6.73
Jedd Gyorko 2B $21.00 $22.94 $14.93 $6.67
Shane Victorino OF $6.18 $8.31 $5.80 $6.65
A.J. Ellis C $6.14 $7.59 $5.79 $6.62
Omar Infante 2B $7.96 $11.34 $5.63 $6.44
Victor Martinez 1B $4.03 $10.64 $5.53 $6.33
Lance Berkman Util $0.67 $- $5.36 $6.13
Justin Morneau 1B $- $1.63 $5.31 $6.08
Adam Lind 1B $7.34 $11.66 $5.26 $6.02
Norichika Aoki OF $9.22 $14.56 $5.20 $5.96
Khris Davis OF $6.58 $2.07 $5.18 $5.94
Coco Crisp OF $11.28 $17.12 $5.09 $5.83
Daniel Nava OF $6.72 $0.33 $4.68 $5.36
Will Middlebrooks 3B $5.69 $6.80 $4.64 $5.32
Melky Cabrera OF $6.31 $9.13 $4.50 $5.15
Jonny Gomes OF $4.22 $- $4.50 $5.15
Angel Pagan OF $7.45 $11.26 $4.43 $5.08
Dayan Viciedo OF $1.58 $- $4.40 $5.04
Daniel Murphy 2B $8.26 $14.44 $4.34 $4.97
Yadier Molina C $12.12 $16.58 $4.17 $4.78
Brandon Phillips 2B $11.33 $16.38 $3.94 $4.51
Evan Gattis C $16.90 $18.94 $3.87 $4.43
Derek Jeter SS $7.34 $9.57 $3.81 $4.37
Curtis Granderson OF $12.72 $8.38 $3.70 $4.24
David Freese 3B $2.64 $0.00 $3.49 $3.99
David Murphy OF $7.20 $6.67 $3.26 $3.73
Alexei Ramirez SS $7.47 $22.61 $3.20 $3.66
Steve Pearce OF $- $- $3.06 $3.51
George Springer OF $- $- $2.94 $3.37
Mike Carp OF $- $- $2.93 $3.35
Marco Scutaro 2B $10.35 $12.15 $2.88 $3.29
Jimmy Rollins SS $8.25 $15.57 $2.77 $3.17
Desmond Jennings OF $8.04 $12.48 $2.75 $3.15
Corey Hart Util $3.08 $7.23 $2.35 $2.69
Mark Reynolds 3B $- $- $2.32 $2.66
Nolan Arenado 3B $2.01 $5.81 $2.19 $2.51
Alex Rios OF $5.75 $16.34 $1.88 $2.15
Jonathan Lucroy C $12.76 $17.07 $1.87 $2.14
Gerardo Parra OF $8.02 $10.23 $1.83 $2.10
Chris Colabello OF $4.81 $- $1.82 $2.08
Ike Davis 1B $- $- $1.71 $1.96
Travis Snider OF $5.43 $4.08 $1.70 $1.94
Nate Schierholtz OF $4.04 $3.27 $1.63 $1.87
Justin Ruggiano OF $- $- $1.62 $1.86
Wilson Ramos C $11.72 $13.38 $1.62 $1.85
Oscar Taveras OF $- $- $1.56 $1.79
Michael Choice OF $- $- $1.47 $1.68
Brett Wallace 3B $5.56 $6.07 $1.43 $1.63
Darin Ruf OF $- $- $1.37 $1.57
Ryan Howard 1B $- $- $1.26 $1.44
Josh Reddick OF $6.67 $4.47 $1.22 $1.40
Eric Chavez 3B $- $- $1.20 $1.37
Rickie Weeks 2B $- $- $1.18 $1.36
Will Venable OF $6.67 $10.39 $1.17 $1.34
Charlie Culberson SS $- $- $1.71 $1.21
Charlie Blackmon OF $- $- $0.85 $0.98
Dan Uggla 2B $8.64 $0.00 $0.81 $0.92
Carl Crawford OF $5.76 $10.47 $0.80 $0.91
Leonys Martin OF $1.12 $10.50 $0.79 $0.91
Chris Johnson 3B $- $- $0.79 $0.91
Paul Konerko 1B $- $- $0.77 $0.88
Ryan Raburn OF $- $- $0.62 $0.71
Grant Green 2B $- $- $0.61 $0.70
Stephen Drew SS $8.67 $8.41 $0.55 $0.63
Jesus Guzman OF $- $- $0.54 $0.62
Jon Jay OF $- $- $0.45 $0.52
David DeJesus OF $5.65 $5.05 $0.41 $0.46
Lucas Duda OF $- $- $0.39 $0.44
Andrew Lambo OF $- $- $0.39 $0.44
Kyle Seager 3B $3.54 $5.31 $0.35 $0.40
Adam Dunn 1B $6.84 $3.58 $0.21 $0.24
Didi Gregorius SS $3.56 $5.60 $0.19 $0.22
Alex Avila C $10.84 $7.95 $0.16 $0.18
Chris Owings SS $- $- $0.13 $0.15
Scott Van Slyke OF $- $- $0.13 $0.15
Henry Urrutia OF $- $- $0.11 $0.13
Dean Anna SS $- $- $0.70 $0.12
Jose Tabata OF $2.68 $2.99 $0.09 $0.10
Adam LaRoche 1B $- $- $0.07 $0.08
Corban Joseph 2B $- $- $0.04 $0.04
Mat Gamel Util $- $- $0.03 $0.03
Carlos Ruiz C $7.90 $8.85 $0.00 $0.00
Andy Dirks OF $- $- $0.00 $0.00
Jaff Decker OF $- $- $- $-
Logan Morrison 1B $0.00 $0.34 $- $-
Todd Frazier 3B $- $- $- $-
Jason Kubel OF $- $- $- $-
Jackie Bradley OF $3.74 $4.04 $- $-
Gordon Beckham 2B $2.28 $- $- $-
David Cooper Util $- $- $- $-
Kolten Wong 2B $3.95 $9.62 $- $-
Ryan Wheeler 3B $- $- $- $-
Zoilo Almonte OF $- $- $- $-
Josh Vitters 3B $- $- $- $-
Joc Pederson OF $- $- $- $-
Ehire Adrianza SS $- $- $- $-
Mike Zunino C $5.25 $10.57 $- $-
Thomas Neal OF $- $- $- $-
Brent Keys OF $- $- $- $-
Charlie Cutler C $- $- $- $-
Caleb Gindl OF $- $- $- $-
Jake Elmore SS $- $- $- $-
Eric Fryer C $- $- $- $-
Scott Moore 3B $- $- $- $-
Jason Rogers OF $- $- $- $-
Ryan Kalish Util $- $- $- $-
Jim Adduci OF $- $- $- $-
Brady Shoemaker Util $- $- $- $-
Shane Peterson OF $- $- $- $-
Brandon Allen OF $- $- $- $-
Alex Castellanos OF $- $- $- $-
Michael Taylor OF $- $- $- $-
Brandon Guyer OF $- $- $- $-
Alen Hanson SS $- $- $- $-
Drew Stubbs OF $- $- $- $-
Nick Buss OF $- $- $- $-
Luis Jimenez 3B $- $- $- $-
Addison Russell SS $- $- $- $-
Gary Sanchez C $- $- $- $-
Irving Falu SS $- $- $- $-
Michael Young 3B $- $4.13 $- $-
Josh Harrison SS $- $- $0.56 $-
Daric Barton 3B $- $- $- $-
Bryce Brentz OF $- $- $- $-
Maikel Franco 3B $- $- $- $-
Justin Bour 1B $- $- $- $-
Steve Susdorf OF $- $- $- $-
Andrew Brown OF $- $- $- $-
Alfredo Silverio Util $- $- $- $-
Justin Maxwell OF $- $- $- $-
John Baker C $- $- $- $-
Yunel Escobar SS $4.98 $7.00 $- $-
Yasmani Grandal C $2.37 $- $- $-
Brett Jackson OF $- $- $- $-
Carlos Triunfel SS $- $- $- $-
Kevin Mattison OF $- $- $- $-
Tony Abreu 2B $- $- $- $-
Melky Mesa OF $- $- $- $-
Robert Andino SS $- $- $- $-
J.R. Murphy C $- $- $- $-
Andrew Susac C $- $- $- $-
Brock Peterson 1B $- $- $- $-
Trayce Thompson OF $- $- $- $-
Andy Parrino SS $- $- $- $-
Johnny Giavotella 2B $- $- $0.31 $-
Ryan Lavarnway C $- $- $- $-
Jordany Valdespin 2B $- $- $- $-
Reid Brignac SS $- $- $- $-
Brett Gardner OF $2.37 $8.61 $- $-
Greg Miclat SS $- $- $- $-
Kirk Nieuwenhuis OF $- $- $- $-
Alex Hassan OF $- $- $- $-
Chase d’Arnaud SS $- $- $- $-
Ryan Lamarre OF $- $- $- $-
Christian Vazquez C $- $- $- $-
Hunter Morris 1B $- $- $- $-
Zach Lutz 3B $- $- $- $-
Jordy Mercer SS $1.39 $- $1.36 $-
Michael Brantley OF $- $1.64 $- $-
Jose Constanza OF $- $- $- $-
Shane Robinson OF $- $- $- $-
Mitch Moreland 1B $- $3.63 $- $-
Tyler Moore OF $- $- $- $-
Nick Franklin 2B $- $- $- $-
Derek Dietrich 2B $- $- $- $-
Steve Clevenger C $- $- $- $-
Tony Campana OF $- $- $- $-
Ryan Sweeney OF $- $- $- $-
Johnny Monell C $- $- $- $-
J.D. Martinez OF $- $- $- $-
Lane Adams OF $- $- $- $-
Mike Baxter OF $- $- $- $-
Hernan Perez SS $- $- $- $-
Joey Terdoslavich OF $- $- $- $-
Jordan Lennerton 1B $- $- $- $-
Alfredo Marte OF $- $- $- $-
Luke Montz C $- $- $- $-
Dustin Garneau C $- $- $- $-
David Adams 2B $- $- $- $-
Tony Sanchez C $- $- $- $-
Austin Romine C $- $- $- $-
Alfonso Soriano OF $2.50 $1.91 $- $-
Tommy Medica 1B $- $- $- $-
Scott Hairston OF $- $- $- $-
Chris McGuiness 1B $- $- $- $-
Rafael Furcal SS $- $- $- $-
Garin Cecchini 3B $- $- $- $-
Francisco Lindor SS $- $- $- $-
Josh Thole C $- $- $- $-
Eric Sogard SS $- $- $0.53 $-
A.J. Jimenez C $- $- $- $-
Steven Lerud C $- $- $- $-
Anthony Rendon 2B $12.58 $10.69 $7.95 $-
Avisail Garcia OF $3.02 $9.87 $- $-
Marc Krauss OF $- $- $- $-
Brandon Hicks SS $- $- $- $-
Casper Wells OF $- $- $- $-
Marlon Byrd OF $- $- $- $-
Cliff Pennington SS $- $- $- $-
Ramon Cabrera C $- $- $- $-
Clete Thomas OF $- $- $- $-
Gregory Polanco OF $- $- $- $-
Logan Watkins 2B $- $- $- $-
Josh Prince SS $- $- $- $-
Donald Lutz OF $- $- $- $-
Reymond Fuentes OF $- $- $- $-
Jose Ramirez SS $- $- $- $-
Audry Perez C $- $- $- $-
Max Stassi C $- $- $- $-
Daniel Butler C $- $- $- $-
Juan Centeno C $- $- $- $-
Chris Gimenez C $- $- $- $-
Kyle Jensen OF $- $- $- $-
Jermaine Curtis 3B $- $- $- $-
Corky Miller C $- $- $- $-
John Hester C $- $- $- $-
Kyle Blanks OF $- $- $- $-
Ryan Ludwick OF $2.00 $- $- $-
Ryan Roberts 2B $- $- $- $-
Juan Francisco 3B $1.04 $- $- $-
Lou Marson C $- $- $- $-
Donnie Murphy SS $- $- $1.95 $-
Jon Singleton 1B $- $- $- $-
Marcus Semien SS $- $- $2.37 $-
Kelly Shoppach C $- $- $- $-
Cesar Hernandez 2B $- $- $- $-
Jared Mitchell OF $- $- $- $-
Rob Johnson C $- $- $- $-
Dave Sappelt OF $- $- $- $-
Alex Rodriguez 3B $- $- $- $-
Lonnie Chisenhall 3B $- $- $- $-
Chad Tracy 3B $- $- $- $-
Adron Chambers OF $- $- $- $-
Rene Rivera C $- $- $- $-
Tommy Field SS $- $- $- $-
Rob Brantly C $- $- $- $-
Alejandro De Aza OF $0.18 $- $- $-
Pete Orr SS $- $- $- $-
Kyle Skipworth C $- $- $- $-
Josh Satin 3B $- $- $- $-
Mike Moustakas 3B $- $- $- $-
Brandon Barnes OF $- $- $- $-
Chris Heisey OF $- $- $- $-
Steve Lombardozzi 2B $- $- $- $-
Jemile Weeks SS $- $- $- $-
Sebastian Valle C $- $- $- $-
Joe Mahoney 1B $- $- $- $-
Brian Roberts 2B $0.25 $- $- $-
Michael Bourn OF $0.27 $12.29 $- $-
Christian Yelich OF $- $- $- $-
Chris Valaika SS $- $- $- $-
Vernon Wells OF $- $- $- $-
Michael Almanzar 3B $- $- $- $-
Dustin Ackley 2B $2.42 $- $- $-
Kristopher Negron SS $- $- $- $-
Yan Gomes C $8.42 $10.60 $- $-
Manny Machado 3B $- $- $- $-
A.J. Pollock OF $- $- $- $-
Craig Gentry OF $- $- $- $-
Michael McKenry C $- $- $- $-
Pete Kozma SS $- $- $- $-
Brian Bogusevic OF $- $- $- $-
Neftali Soto 3B $- $- $- $-
Jonathan Villar SS $2.34 $14.74 $- $-
Chris Denorfia OF $- $- $- $-
Francisco Peguero OF $- $- $- $-
Jose Lobaton C $- $- $- $-
Tyler Pastornicky 2B $- $- $- $-
Todd Cunningham OF $- $- $- $-
Eury Perez OF $- $- $- $-
Ryan Jackson SS $- $- $- $-
Felix Pie OF $- $- $- $-
Adam Rosales SS $- $- $- $-
Phil Gosselin 2B $- $- $- $-
George Kottaras C $- $- $- $-
Welington Castillo C $8.53 $9.02 $- $-
Jordan Danks OF $- $- $- $-
Gerald Laird C $- $- $- $-
Nick Noonan 2B $- $- $- $-
Corey Brown OF $- $- $- $-
Zack Cozart SS $3.30 $10.01 $- $-
Cody Clark C $- $- $- $-
Henry Rodriguez 2B $- $- $- $-
Carlos Corporan C $- $- $- $-
Sean Halton OF $- $- $- $-
Endy Chavez OF $- $- $- $-
Delmon Young OF $- $- $- $-
Chris Getz 2B $- $- $- $-
Jason Pridie OF $- $- $- $-
Danny Santana SS $- $- $- $-
Juan Perez OF $- $- $- $-
Xander Bogaerts SS $14.60 $17.72 $9.37 $-
Kevin Frandsen 2B $- $- $- $-
Drew Butera C $- $- $- $-
Scooter Gennett 2B $- $1.15 $- $-
Eduardo Nunez SS $- $- $- $-
Scott Sizemore Util $- $- $- $-
Hector Sanchez C $- $- $- $-
Logan Forsythe SS $- $- $- $-
Chris Snyder C $- $- $- $-
Bryan Anderson C $- $- $- $-
John Buck C $- $- $- $-
Alex Presley OF $2.05 $4.76 $- $-
Miguel Tejada 2B $- $- $- $-
Carlos Pena 1B $- $- $- $-
Jimmy Paredes SS $- $- $- $-
Abraham Almonte OF $- $- $- $-
Brock Holt SS $- $- $- $-
Matt den Dekker OF $- $- $- $-
Kevin Pillar OF $- $- $- $-
Collin Cowgill OF $- $- $- $-
Zach Walters SS $- $- $- $-
Jonathan Herrera SS $- $- $- $-
Dee Gordon SS $- $- $- $-
Robinson Chirinos C $- $- $- $-
Jeff Baker OF $- $- $- $-
Francisco Cervelli C $- $- $- $-
John Mayberry OF $- $- $- $-
Raul Ibanez OF $1.08 $- $- $-
Conor Gillaspie 3B $- $- $- $-
Travis d’Arnaud C $8.66 $10.61 $- $-
Quintin Berry OF $- $- $- $-
Nolan Reimold OF $- $- $- $-
Brett Hayes C $- $- $- $-
Brandon Crawford SS $2.48 $6.87 $- $-
Omar Quintanilla SS $- $- $- $-
Wilson Betemit Util $- $- $- $-
Jason Giambi Util $- $- $- $-
Jarrod Dyson OF $- $- $- $-
Derek Norris C $4.55 $2.37 $- $-
Matt Davidson 3B $- $- $- $-
Humberto Quintero C $- $- $- $-
Francisco Martinez OF $- $- $- $-
Aaron Hicks OF $- $- $- $-
Danny Espinosa SS $- $- $- $-
Luis Valbuena 2B $- $- $0.36 $-
Wilfredo Tovar SS $- $- $- $-
Danny Valencia Util $- $- $- $-
Chris B. Young OF $4.33 $3.42 $- $-
Travis Hafner Util $- $- $- $-
Stephen Vogt C $- $- $- $-
Chris Coghlan OF $- $- $- $-
Moises Sierra OF $- $- $- $-
Cody Asche 3B $- $- $- $-
Jayson Nix SS $- $- $- $-
Tim Federowicz C $- $- $- $-
Garrett Jones OF $1.18 $- $- $-
Pedro Ciriaco SS $- $- $- $-
John Jaso C $9.53 $7.32 $- $-
Jonathan Schoop SS $- $- $- $-
Anthony Recker C $- $- $- $-
Cord Phelps 2B $- $- $- $-
Gaby Sanchez 1B $- $- $- $-
Chris Iannetta C $2.21 $- $- $-
Christian Bethancourt C $- $- $- $-
Cameron Maybin OF $- $- $- $-
Jordan Pacheco C $- $- $- $-
Willie Bloomquist SS $- $- $- $-
Jake Marisnick OF $- $- $- $-
Matt Diaz Util $- $- $- $-
Lorenzo Cain OF $- $- $- $-
Tyler Flowers C $- $- $- $-
Josmil Pinto C $2.65 $2.28 $- $-
Sandy Leon C $- $- $- $-
Laynce Nix OF $- $- $- $-
Chris Stewart C $- $- $- $-
Nate Freiman 1B $- $- $- $-
Michael Martinez SS $- $- $- $-
Kevin Kiermaier OF $- $- $- $-
Seth Smith OF $- $- $- $-
Roger Bernadina OF $- $- $- $-
Matt Dominguez 3B $- $0.02 $- $-
Ryan Flaherty 2B $0.00 $- $- $-
Wil Nieves C $- $- $- $-
Mark Ellis 2B $- $- $- $-
L.J. Hoes OF $- $- $- $-
Jeff Keppinger 2B $- $- $- $-
Jeff Kobernus OF $- $- $- $-
Tuffy Gosewisch C $- $- $- $-
Yonder Alonso 1B $- $0.00 $- $-
Austin Kearns Util $- $- $- $-
Alexi Amarista SS $- $- $- $-
Engel Beltre OF $- $- $- $-
Nick Castellanos OF $0.00 $2.69 $- $-
Dioner Navarro C $4.38 $4.66 $- $-
Peter Bourjos OF $- $- $- $-
Placido Polanco 3B $- $- $- $-
Ryan Doumit C $4.04 $4.78 $- $-
Miguel Olivo C $- $- $- $-
David Ross C $- $- $- $-
Skip Schumaker 2B $- $- $- $-
Ichiro Suzuki OF $- $- $- $-
Andrew Romine SS $- $- $- $-
Trevor Plouffe 3B $- $- $- $-
Rajai Davis OF $- $4.11 $- $-
Marwin Gonzalez SS $- $- $- $-
Anthony Gose OF $- $- $- $-
Erik Kratz C $1.47 $- $- $-
Michael Saunders OF $4.93 $6.30 $- $-
Geovany Soto C $3.22 $1.02 $- $-
Donovan Solano 2B $- $- $- $-
Wilmer Flores 2B $- $- $- $-
Yuniesky Betancourt 3B $- $- $- $-
Logan Schafer OF $- $- $- $-
Kelly Johnson 2B $4.39 $- $- $-
Brian Dozier 2B $6.15 $11.33 $- $-
Alexi Casilla 2B $- $- $- $-
Leury Garcia SS $- $- $- $-
Darnell McDonald OF $- $- $- $-
Sam Fuld OF $- $- $- $-
DJ LeMahieu SS $3.42 $12.51 $3.84 $-
Chris Herrmann C $- $- $- $-
Mike Aviles SS $- $- $- $-
A.J. Pierzynski C $- $2.12 $- $-
Tony Cruz C $- $- $- $-
Emilio Bonifacio 2B $- $- $- $-
Devin Mesoraco C $7.03 $10.04 $- $-
Gregor Blanco OF $- $- $- $-
Nate McLouth OF $- $0.03 $- $-
Daniel Descalso SS $- $- $- $-
J.B. Shuck OF $- $- $- $-
B.J. Upton OF $- $- $- $-
Justin Sellers SS $- $- $- $-
Don Kelly OF $- $- $- $-
Jack Hannahan 3B $- $- $- $-
Sean Rodriguez OF $- $- $- $-
Hak-Ju Lee Util $- $- $- $-
Jesus Sucre C $- $- $- $-
Koyie Hill C $- $- $- $-
Justin Smoak 1B $- $- $- $-
Eric Young OF $- $- $- $-
Brayan Pena C $- $- $- $-
Hank Conger C $3.56 $5.22 $- $-
Ruben Tejada SS $- $1.69 $- $-
Marcell Ozuna OF $- $1.25 $- $-
Justin Turner SS $- $- $0.02 $-
Alberto Callaspo 2B $1.67 $- $- $-
Robbie Grossman OF $- $- $- $-
Cameron Rupp C $- $- $- $-
David Lough OF $- $- $- $-
Darin Mastroianni OF $- $- $- $-
Ramiro Pena SS $- $- $- $-
J.P. Arencibia C $3.63 $5.11 $- $-
Junior Lake OF $- $2.80 $- $-
Jurickson Profar SS $10.10 $15.04 $3.67 $-
Joaquin Arias SS $- $- $- $-
Cesar Izturis SS $- $- $- $-
Chris Nelson 3B $- $- $- $-
Bryan Holaday C $- $- $- $-
Kurt Suzuki C $- $- $- $-
James Loney 1B $- $- $- $-
Ryan Hanigan C $- $- $- $-
Jarrod Saltalamacchia C $3.82 $4.82 $- $-
Alcides Escobar SS $- $14.09 $- $-
Nick Punto SS $- $- $- $-
Greg Dobbs 1B $- $- $- $-
Casey Kotchman 1B $- $- $- $-
Ed Lucas 2B $- $- $- $-
Henry Blanco C $- $- $- $-
Freddy Galvis SS $- $- $- $-
Mike Olt 3B $- $- $- $-
Clint Barmes SS $- $- $- $-
Yorvit Torrealba C $- $- $- $-
Ramon Santiago SS $- $- $- $-
Eduardo Escobar SS $- $- $- $-
Russell Martin C $5.46 $8.14 $- $-
Nick Green SS $- $- $- $-
Cody Ransom 3B $- $- $- $-
Jhonatan Solano C $- $- $- $-
Denard Span OF $- $2.26 $- $-
Jose Molina C $- $- $- $-
Pedro Florimon SS $- $1.67 $- $-
Ben Revere OF $- $5.73 $- $-
Brendan Ryan SS $- $- $- $-
Darwin Barney 2B $- $- $- $-
Josh Phegley C $- $5.30 $- $-
Taylor Teagarden C $- $0.50 $- $-
Nick Hundley C $- $- $- $-
Jordan Schafer OF $- $- $- $-
Franklin Gutierrez OF $- $- $- $-
Juan Uribe 3B $- $- $- $-
Juan Pierre OF $- $- $- $-
Maicer Izturis SS $0.84 $4.27 $- $-
Juan Lagares OF $- $- $- $-
Casey McGehee Util $- $- $- $-
Ryan Goins SS $- $- $- $-
Billy Hamilton OF $- $18.48 $- $-
Jeff Bianchi SS $- $- $- $-
Adeiny Hechavarria SS $- $0.00 $- $-
Lyle Overbay 1B $- $- $- $-
Jeff Mathis C $- $- $- $-
Martin Maldonado C $- $0.00 $- $-
Jamey Carroll 2B $- $0.16 $- $-
Jose Iglesias SS $- $8.56 $- $-

Pitchers

Name Pos 4×4 5×5 FG Pts SABR Pts
Clayton Kershaw SP $41.42 $25.25 $37.62 $32.11
Felix Hernandez SP $38.22 $21.35 $33.44 $26.75
Stephen Strasburg SP $38.16 $20.80 $36.78 $35.25
Adam Wainwright SP $36.99 $19.53 $28.98 $18.53
Yu Darvish SP $36.95 $24.10 $39.52 $41.84
Cliff Lee SP $33.09 $22.34 $28.97 $15.19
Madison Bumgarner SP $32.51 $19.26 $29.89 $24.97
Doug Fister SP $32.10 $14.91 $21.59 $10.92
Jose Fernandez SP $31.67 $15.81 $33.86 $36.19
Chris Sale SP $31.30 $20.09 $30.00 $24.06
Zack Greinke SP $30.65 $17.15 $25.36 $18.11
David Price SP $29.45 $18.47 $24.04 $15.01
Alex Cobb SP $28.43 $12.57 $22.65 $20.53
A.J. Burnett SP $26.09 $11.73 $24.78 $25.03
Max Scherzer SP $26.05 $22.15 $27.11 $21.19
Hyun-Jin Ryu SP $25.56 $13.50 $21.09 $16.11
Danny Salazar SP $23.23 $16.76 $26.30 $25.91
Cole Hamels SP $22.92 $15.83 $20.43 $10.39
Andrew Cashner SP $22.45 $8.92 $18.93 $15.45
Anibal Sanchez SP $21.82 $15.49 $21.13 $14.53
Justin Masterson SP $21.01 $7.97 $17.17 $17.20
Gio Gonzalez SP $20.99 $10.15 $23.04 $24.43
Craig Kimbrel RP $20.86 $16.13 $33.68 $37.74
James Shields SP $20.37 $11.79 $16.19 $9.19
Francisco Liriano SP $19.76 $7.56 $22.91 $27.16
Josh Johnson SP $19.15 $7.25 $18.34 $16.57
Dan Haren SP $18.19 $14.12 $12.82 $0.10
Jeff Samardzija SP $18.19 $9.36 $19.32 $19.03
Patrick Corbin SP $18.04 $10.45 $14.63 $8.26
Kris Medlen SP $17.78 $9.22 $13.78 $5.10
Lance Lynn SP $17.78 $8.90 $17.70 $17.20
Justin Verlander SP $17.72 $15.67 $17.55 $10.76
Ian Kennedy SP $17.55 $12.75 $14.19 $8.32
Hisashi Iwakuma SP $17.17 $9.68 $13.88 $4.70
Aroldis Chapman RP $17.07 $14.67 $32.48 $39.10
Scott Kazmir SP $16.48 $10.23 $16.74 $13.30
Tim Lincecum SP $16.05 $7.38 $18.08 $19.07
CC Sabathia SP $15.97 $9.76 $13.46 $5.37
Tony Cingrani SP $15.93 $12.67 $22.34 $25.83
Michael Wacha SP $15.38 $8.42 $16.00 $12.74
Rick Porcello SP $15.11 $6.04 $9.15 $-
Kenley Jansen RP $14.92 $13.94 $26.93 $29.64
Shelby Miller SP $14.35 $9.53 $15.18 $14.52
Gerrit Cole SP $14.30 $4.67 $13.86 $13.34
Jordan Zimmermann SP $14.14 $8.33 $9.86 $-
Johnny Cueto SP $14.13 $6.95 $10.28 $2.75
Bartolo Colon SP $13.57 $8.66 $8.35 $-
Greg Holland RP $13.22 $11.64 $25.73 $29.45
Koji Uehara RP $13.15 $13.78 $23.04 $21.78
Matt Garza SP $12.95 $10.03 $12.03 $4.73
John Lackey SP $12.35 $8.26 $7.71 $-
Hiroki Kuroda SP $12.25 $8.03 $7.25 $-
Arodys Vizcaino SP $12.23 $6.15 $15.47 $16.86
Mat Latos SP $12.14 $9.77 $11.92 $5.07
Tyson Ross SP $12.09 $1.25 $12.30 $14.56
Ivan Nova SP $12.06 $5.32 $8.74 $3.53
Trevor Rosenthal RP $11.77 $10.67 $22.25 $24.78
Jon Niese SP $11.60 $3.26 $9.28 $4.28
Matt Cain SP $11.26 $10.69 $8.92 $0.07
Tim Hudson SP $11.25 $1.80 $4.82 $-
Jon Lester SP $11.24 $5.38 $9.31 $5.35
Ervin Santana SP $10.99 $7.37 $8.37 $-
Corey Kluber SP $10.87 $5.74 $10.31 $6.55
Homer Bailey SP $10.72 $6.92 $10.49 $3.49
Mark Melancon RP $10.62 $8.64 $17.74 $17.24
Joaquin Benoit RP $10.59 $3.06 $19.68 $21.53
Henderson Alvarez SP $10.42 $- $3.21 $-
Charlie Morton SP $10.30 $- $4.31 $1.79
Roberto Hernandez SP $10.18 $0.49 $5.62 $-
Jason Grilli RP $10.09 $3.71 $22.00 $23.98
Alex Wood SP $9.64 $0.32 $11.27 $11.51
Tanner Roark SP $9.33 $2.36 $6.63 $1.21
Ubaldo Jimenez SP $9.32 $5.86 $13.47 $15.75
Gavin Floyd SP $9.30 $1.68 $8.77 $6.15
Trevor Cahill SP $9.15 $- $5.80 $6.36
Kelvin Herrera RP $8.74 $- $8.25 $9.01
Jake McGee RP $8.49 $9.74 $20.07 $22.38
Mike Minor SP $8.48 $9.84 $8.80 $1.04
Glen Perkins RP $8.17 $9.43 $19.17 $20.34
Will Smith RP $7.96 $2.44 $- $-
David Robertson RP $7.87 $8.56 $18.55 $20.25
Yovani Gallardo SP $7.84 $2.05 $10.14 $7.81
Kevin Gausman SP $7.76 $7.21 $9.28 $3.65
Carlos Torres SP $7.63 $3.78 $6.65 $1.69
Julio Teheran SP $7.62 $8.18 $5.34 $-
Jenrry Mejia SP $7.60 $- $7.97 $7.23
Sonny Gray SP $7.54 $2.11 $8.26 $7.62
Edwin Jackson SP $7.03 $2.02 $6.78 $1.51
Marco Estrada SP $6.49 $6.69 $7.34 $0.36
Wade Miley SP $6.15 $2.21 $4.77 $-
Derek Holland SP $5.97 $6.04 $7.39 $1.59
Bobby Parnell RP $5.91 $6.31 $14.95 $16.01
Jonny Venters RP $5.80 $- $4.67 $6.79
Fernando Rodney RP $5.75 $- $5.66 $7.58
Sergio Romo RP $5.61 $7.70 $14.37 $12.90
Steve Cishek RP $5.41 $5.87 $15.04 $17.18
Matt Moore SP $5.14 $7.16 $9.44 $13.24
Sergio Santos RP $5.08 $0.03 $14.18 $16.15
Brett Anderson SP $5.06 $- $6.48 $6.84
Zack Wheeler SP $4.96 $1.48 $8.10 $12.72
Rafael Montero SP $4.86 $- $6.24 $2.66
Danny Farquhar RP $4.79 $6.97 $16.21 $19.01
Jaime Garcia SP $4.56 $- $5.79 $3.60
Jordan Walden RP $4.36 $- $4.46 $4.97
Brandon McCarthy SP $4.30 $0.42 $- $-
Clay Buchholz SP $4.29 $0.03 $4.96 $2.25
Seth Maness RP $4.21 $- $- $-
Jim Johnson RP $4.15 $4.64 $10.44 $9.71
Joe Blanton SP $4.14 $0.97 $3.47 $-
Kevin Siegrist RP $4.00 $- $- $-
Wandy Rodriguez SP $3.89 $1.46 $1.24 $-
C.J. Wilson SP $3.84 $1.31 $6.85 $6.86
Nate Jones RP $3.84 $6.09 $15.49 $18.34
Junichi Tazawa RP $3.83 $- $10.01 $8.96
Pedro Strop RP $3.74 $- $2.66 $4.73
Brian Wilson RP $3.67 $- $5.46 $6.87
J.J. Putz RP $3.54 $- $8.53 $8.98
Jake Peavy SP $3.49 $5.69 $2.45 $-
Josh Beckett SP $3.42 $- $4.85 $2.32
Joe Nathan RP $3.39 $7.57 $13.86 $13.98
Felix Doubront SP $3.36 $- $6.42 $7.79
Jonathan Papelbon RP $3.34 $7.62 $13.16 $11.63
Jamey Wright RP $3.15 $- $0.19 $-
Neal Cotts RP $2.97 $- $3.16 $3.73
Brandon Beachy SP $2.92 $4.18 $5.28 $1.83
Burch Smith RP $2.89 $- $- $-
Paco Rodriguez RP $2.83 $- $1.12 $1.95
Andrew Miller RP $2.79 $- $3.55 $6.70
Jesse Crain RP $2.66 $0.00 $10.78 $12.14
Randy Choate RP $2.62 $- $1.33 $1.56
Dillon Gee SP $2.61 $0.75 $0.89 $-
Addison Reed RP $2.60 $7.04 $12.79 $13.48
Ernesto Frieri RP $2.60 $8.52 $14.81 $17.97
Cory Luebke SP $2.54 $- $5.71 $5.15
Bruce Rondon RP $2.45 $- $8.72 $13.32
Casey Janssen RP $2.37 $5.59 $11.80 $10.96
A.J. Griffin SP $2.37 $7.39 $0.58 $-
Brandon Kintzler RP $2.36 $- $1.39 $0.14
Cody Allen RP $2.28 $- $11.49 $13.31
Brad Ziegler RP $2.24 $- $- $-
Aaron Crow RP $2.23 $- $3.49 $5.03
Drew Smyly SP $2.21 $1.97 $5.39 $2.68
Luke Hochevar RP $2.19 $- $- $-
Drew Storen RP $2.10 $- $0.95 $-
Brandon Workman SP $2.09 $- $4.37 $2.53
Tim Stauffer RP $2.02 $- $- $-
Sean Doolittle RP $1.95 $- $0.85 $-
Nick Vincent RP $1.88 $- $0.49 $-
Tommy Milone SP $1.84 $- $2.66 $-
Joe Kelly SP $1.78 $- $0.25 $-
Ryan Dempster SP $1.74 $- $4.27 $2.99
Grant Balfour RP $1.71 $5.81 $13.03 $15.29
Manny Parra RP $1.68 $- $2.02 $2.84
Rex Brothers RP $1.66 $- $7.48 $11.49
Jeff Francis SP $1.63 $1.28 $- $-
Jeanmar Gomez SP $1.44 $- $1.56 $-
Carlos Villanueva SP $1.34 $- $2.83 $-
Huston Street RP $1.34 $6.00 $10.70 $9.90
Ryan Cook RP $1.32 $- $0.39 $0.70
Charlie Furbush RP $1.28 $- $1.35 $1.66
Al Alburquerque RP $1.28 $- $3.72 $7.87
Carlos Martinez RP $1.28 $- $- $-
Justin Grimm SP $1.27 $- $3.10 $1.36
Jim Henderson RP $1.04 $5.71 $13.80 $17.14
Craig Stammen RP $0.94 $- $- $-
Dale Thayer RP $0.84 $- $- $-
Mike Leake SP $0.83 $- $- $-
Javier Lopez RP $0.75 $- $- $-
Mike Dunn RP $0.74 $- $4.65 $7.07
Tyler Lyons RP $0.67 $- $- $-
Jerome Williams SP $0.38 $- $- $-
Justin Wilson RP $0.34 $- $- $0.43
Sean Marshall RP $0.34 $- $- $-
Luis Avilan RP $0.31 $- $- $0.49
Jose Veras RP $0.16 $4.49 $10.98 $13.74
Gonzalez Germen RP $0.10 $- $0.90 $-
J.P. Howell RP $0.08 $- $- $-
Kyle McPherson SP $0.08 $- $2.11 $0.07
R.A. Dickey SP $0.02 $3.09 $- $-
Brad Boxberger RP $- $- $- $-
Chris Archer SP $- $- $2.80 $5.91
Carlos Carrasco SP $- $- $1.63 $-
LaTroy Hawkins RP $- $3.42 $7.53 $5.37
Tyler Clippard RP $- $- $6.42 $6.39
Brett Cecil RP $- $- $- $-
Jeff Karstens SP $- $- $- $-
Boone Logan RP $- $- $- $-
Shawn Kelley RP $- $- $6.70 $7.09
David Hale SP $- $- $0.43 $-
Alex Torres RP $- $- $0.47 $3.39
Nathan Eovaldi SP $- $- $2.38 $2.66
Steve Delabar RP $- $- $1.19 $3.28
Marcus Stroman SP $- $- $2.96 $1.62
John Axford RP $- $3.46 $10.58 $12.90
Robbie Ross RP $- $- $- $-
Vic Black RP $- $- $0.00 $2.62
Tony Watson RP $- $- $- $-
Dan Straily SP $- $3.45 $- $-
Danny Duffy SP $- $- $3.60 $6.79
Eric Stults SP $- $0.60 $- $-
Jeremy Affeldt RP $- $- $- $-
Jared Burton RP $- $- $- $-
Tommy Hunter RP $- $5.05 $7.56 $3.94
David Carpenter RP $- $- $- $-
Matt Belisle RP $- $- $- $-
Paul Maholm SP $- $- $- $-
Jerry Blevins RP $- $- $- $-
Antonio Bastardo RP $- $- $6.81 $9.09
Joe Smith RP $- $- $- $-
Jason Hammel SP $- $- $- $-
Scott Feldman SP $- $- $- $-
Heath Bell RP $- $- $- $-
Joakim Soria RP $- $- $0.25 $0.29
A.J. Ramos RP $- $- $- $1.31
David Hernandez RP $- $- $- $-
Chris Perez RP $- $- $- $-
Luke Gregerson RP $- $- $- $-
Mike Adams RP $- $- $- $-
Robbie Erlin SP $- $- $1.86 $0.83
Jonathan Broxton RP $- $- $- $-
Tim Collins RP $- $- $- $1.46
Johan Santana SP $- $2.07 $0.07 $-
Yordano Ventura SP $- $- $2.68 $4.61
Tanner Scheppers RP $- $- $- $-
Jake Arrieta SP $- $- $2.17 $3.27
Aaron Loup RP $- $- $- $-
Jeurys Familia RP $- $- $- $-
Dallas Keuchel SP $- $- $- $-
Tom Gorzelanny RP $- $- $- $-
Heath Hembree RP $- $- $- $-
Garrett Richards SP $- $- $- $-
Jesse Chavez RP $- $- $- $-
Darren Oliver RP $- $- $- $-
Rafael Betancourt RP $- $- $2.98 $0.83
Edinson Volquez SP $- $- $1.30 $2.82
Sam LeCure RP $- $- $- $-
Bryan Shaw RP $- $- $- $-
Jean Machi RP $- $- $- $-
Taylor Jordan SP $- $- $0.55 $-
Casey Fien RP $- $- $- $-
Rafael Soriano RP $- $3.99 $7.33 $6.65
Darren O’Day RP $- $- $0.90 $-
Wily Peralta SP $- $- $0.64 $2.99
Alfredo Figaro RP $- $- $- $-
Jake Diekman RP $- $- $- $-
Yoervis Medina RP $- $- $- $0.00
Ricky Nolasco SP $- $0.73 $- $-
Chris Capuano SP $- $- $- $-
Francisco Rodriguez RP $- $- $- $-
Dan Otero RP $- $- $- $-
Jeff Locke SP $- $- $1.10 $1.71
Michael Pineda SP $- $- $1.52 $0.81
Brian Duensing RP $- $- $- $-
Jarrod Parker SP $- $- $- $-
J.R. Graham SP $- $- $1.03 $0.40
Phil Irwin SP $- $- $0.22 $-
Oliver Perez RP $- $- $- $-
Santiago Casilla RP $- $- $- $-
Yusmeiro Petit SP $- $- $0.91 $-
J.J. Hoover RP $- $- $3.12 $3.85
Matt Harrison SP $- $- $- $-
Zach Lee SP $- $- $1.17 $0.98
Neil Wagner RP $- $- $- $-
Chris Withrow RP $- $- $- $-
Mike Fiers SP $- $- $0.76 $-
Brandon League RP $- $- $- $-
Drew Pomeranz RP $- $- $- $-
Brandon Morrow SP $- $- $0.30 $-
Randall Delgado SP $- $- $- $-
Jose Quintana SP $- $0.17 $- $-
Blake Parker RP $- $- $- $-
Brandon Cumpton SP $- $- $- $-
Kevin Slowey SP $- $- $- $-
Vin Mazzaro RP $- $- $- $-
Kevin Jepsen RP $- $- $- $-
Nate Karns SP $- $- $1.25 $1.77
Joe Wieland SP $- $- $0.86 $0.53
Edward Mujica RP $- $- $- $-
Ross Stripling SP $- $- $0.61 $0.06
Wade Davis SP $- $- $- $-
Scott Rice RP $- $- $- $-
Chad Billingsley SP $- $- $0.53 $0.17
Jose Dominguez RP $- $- $- $-
Tom Wilhelmsen RP $- $- $- $0.53
Adam Ottavino RP $- $- $- $-
Ryan Vogelsong SP $- $- $- $-
Will Harris RP $- $- $- $-
Felipe Paulino RP $- $- $- $-
Chad Qualls RP $- $- $- $-
Vinnie Pestano RP $- $- $- $-
Stephen Pryor RP $- $- $- $-
Louis Coleman RP $- $- $- $-
Justin De Fratus RP $- $- $- $-
Brian Flynn SP $- $- $0.00 $-
Blake Wood RP $- $- $- $-
Matt Lindstrom RP $- $- $- $-
David Phelps SP $- $- $- $-
Erik Davis RP $- $- $- $-
Dane de la Rosa RP $- $- $- $-
Joel Peralta RP $- $- $0.67 $0.22
Ross Detwiler SP $- $- $- $-
Matt Albers RP $- $- $- $-
Ronald Belisario RP $- $- $- $-
Bryan Morris RP $- $- $- $-
Scott Downs RP $- $- $- $-
Jason Motte RP $- $- $- $-
Jared Hughes RP $- $- $- $-
Josh Collmenter RP $- $- $- $-
Xavier Cedeno RP $- $- $- $-
Josh Lueke RP $- $- $- $-
Hector Santiago SP $- $- $- $2.69
Neftali Feliz RP $- $3.09 $7.07 $9.53
Brandon Gomes RP $- $- $- $-
Dustin McGowan RP $- $- $- $-
Taijuan Walker SP $- $- $2.07 $6.54
Dan Jennings RP $- $- $- $-
Cory Gearrin RP $- $- $- $-
Troy Patton RP $- $- $- $-
Joel Hanrahan RP $- $- $- $-
Liam Hendriks SP $- $- $- $-
George Kontos RP $- $- $- $-
Dylan Bundy SP $- $- $0.12 $-
Hector Rondon RP $- $- $- $-
Erik Bedard SP $- $- $0.43 $1.57
Sean Burnett RP $- $- $- $-
Joe Thatcher RP $- $- $- $-
Chaz Roe RP $- $- $- $-
Arquimedes Caminero RP $- $- $- $-
Stephen Fife SP $- $- $- $-
Erasmo Ramirez SP $- $- $- $-
Matt Magill SP $- $- $0.61 $1.99
Chad Bettis SP $- $- $- $-
Alfredo Simon RP $- $- $- $-
Josh Outman RP $- $- $- $-
Joba Chamberlain RP $- $- $- $-
Marc Rzepczynski RP $- $- $- $-
Josh Fields RP $- $2.54 $7.09 $9.56
Christian Garcia RP $- $- $- $-
Brian Matusz RP $- $- $- $-
Michael Tonkin RP $- $- $- $-
Alberto Cabrera RP $- $- $- $-
Alex Colome SP $- $- $- $1.04
Wilton Lopez RP $- $- $- $-
Jeremy Hellickson SP $- $- $- $-
Samuel Deduno SP $- $- $- $-
Kyle Lohse SP $- $- $- $-
Zac Rosscup RP $- $- $- $-
Kyle Gibson SP $- $- $- $-
Yimi Garcia RP $- $- $- $-
John Gast SP $- $- $- $-
Nick Tepesch SP $- $- $- $-
Luis Perez RP $- $- $- $-
Burke Badenhop RP $- $- $- $-
Jason Frasor RP $- $- $- $-
T.J. McFarland RP $- $- $- $-
Ross Ohlendorf RP $- $- $- $-
Yunesky Maya SP $- $- $- $-
Scott Diamond SP $- $- $- $-
Christian Friedrich SP $- $- $- $-
Chien-Ming Wang SP $- $- $- $-
Matt Shoemaker SP $- $- $- $-
Cesar Ramos RP $- $- $- $-
Mike Kickham SP $- $- $- $0.03
Lucas Luetge RP $- $- $- $-
Franklin Morales RP $- $- $- $-
Ryan Mattheus RP $- $- $- $-
Andrew Werner SP $- $- $- $-
Carter Capps RP $- $- $- $-
Trevor May SP $- $- $- $-
Brad Lincoln RP $- $- $- $-
Kyuji Fujikawa RP $- $- $- $-
Zach Phillips RP $- $- $- $-
Jordan Lyles SP $- $- $- $-
Carlos Marmol RP $- $- $- $-
Kyle Farnsworth RP $- $- $- $-
Jeremy Jeffress RP $- $- $- $-
Drew Hutchison RP $- $- $- $-
Jeff Beliveau RP $- $- $- $-
Juan Oviedo RP $- $- $- $-
Sean Nolin SP $- $- $- $-
Joe Savery RP $- $- $- $-
Sam Freeman RP $- $- $- $-
Tyler Skaggs SP $- $- $- $-
Evan Scribner RP $- $- $- $-
Nick Hagadone RP $- $- $- $-
Everett Teaford RP $- $- $- $-
Stolmy Pimentel RP $- $- $- $-
Eric O’Flaherty RP $- $- $- $-
Rubby de la Rosa RP $- $- $- $-
Preston Claiborne RP $- $- $- $-
Chris Hatcher RP $- $- $- $-
Josh Edgin RP $- $- $- $-
Tom Layne RP $- $- $- $-
Wesley Wright RP $- $- $- $-
Phil Coke RP $- $- $- $-
Todd Redmond SP $- $- $- $-
Chris Tillman SP $- $3.28 $- $-
Hiram Burgos SP $- $- $- $-
Jimmy Nelson RP $- $- $- $-
Tyler Thornburg SP $- $- $- $-
Jake Odorizzi SP $- $- $- $-
Andrew Bailey RP $- $- $- $-
Jake Dunning RP $- $- $- $-
Matt Daley RP $- $- $- $-
Cesar Cabral RP $- $- $- $-
Hector Noesi SP $- $- $- $-
Ryan Webb RP $- $- $- $-
Allen Webster SP $- $- $- $-
Grant Dayton RP $- $- $- $-
Adam Warren SP $- $- $- $-
Logan Ondrusek RP $- $- $- $-
Brian Moran RP $- $- $- $-
Anthony Swarzak RP $- $- $- $-
Anthony Varvaro RP $- $- $- $-
Vidal Nuno SP $- $- $- $-
Joe Paterson RP $- $- $- $-
Luis Garcia RP $- $- $- $-
Michael Brady RP $- $- $- $-
Anthony Bass SP $- $- $- $-
Chang-Yong Lim RP $- $- $- $-
Josh Zeid RP $- $- $- $-
Donn Roach RP $- $- $- $-
Chia-Jen Lo RP $- $- $- $-
Arnold Leon RP $- $- $- $-
Erik Cordier RP $- $- $- $-
Tommy Hanson SP $- $- $- $-
Anthony Ranaudo SP $- $- $- $-
Justin Marks SP $- $- $- $-
Rich Hill RP $- $- $- $-
Josh Tomlin RP $- $- $- $-
Nick Masset RP $- $- $- $-
Christian Bergman SP $- $- $- $-
Rob Wooten RP $- $- $- $-
Duke Welker RP $- $- $- $-
Mike Zagurski RP $- $- $- $-
Onelki Garcia RP $- $- $- $-
Zeke Spruill SP $- $- $- $-
B.J. Rosenberg RP $- $- $- $-
Steven Ames RP $- $- $- $-
Octavio Dotel RP $- $- $- $-
Rob Scahill RP $- $- $- $-
Freddy Garcia SP $- $- $- $-
Seth Rosin RP $- $- $- $-
David Huff RP $- $- $- $-
Esmil Rogers SP $- $- $- $-
Luke Putkonen RP $- $- $- $-
Wilmer Font RP $- $- $- $-
Edwar Cabrera RP $- $- $- $-
Matt Langwell RP $- $- $- $-
Javy Guerra RP $- $- $- $-
Juan Gutierrez RP $- $- $- $-
Evan Reed RP $- $- $- $-
Carson Smith RP $- $- $- $-
Dellin Betances RP $- $- $- $-
Brandon Maurer SP $- $- $- $-
Hisanori Takahashi RP $- $- $- $-
C.C. Lee RP $- $- $- $-
Joe Ortiz RP $- $- $- $-
Jose Alvarez SP $- $- $- $-
Drake Britton RP $- $- $- $-
Brooks Raley RP $- $- $- $-
Keith Butler RP $- $- $- $-
Donnie Veal RP $- $- $- $-
Raul Valdes RP $- $- $- $-
Kyle Drabek RP $- $- $- $-
Michael Gonzalez RP $- $- $- $-
Jim Miller RP $- $- $- $-
Michael O’Brien SP $- $- $- $-
Steve Johnson RP $- $- $- $-
Asher Wojciechowski SP $- $- $- $-
Daniel Webb RP $- $- $- $-
Jonathan Pettibone SP $- $- $- $-
Luis Ayala RP $- $- $- $-
James Paxton SP $- $- $0.22 $5.81
Fernando Abad RP $- $- $- $-
Frank Herrmann RP $- $- $- $-
Jeremy Hefner SP $- $- $- $-
Jairo Asencio RP $- $- $- $-
Scott Barnes RP $- $- $- $-
Daniel Stange RP $- $- $- $-
Sam Dyson RP $- $- $- $-
Michael Kohn RP $- $- $- $-
Zach Britton SP $- $- $- $-
Jose De La Torre RP $- $- $- $-
Darin Downs RP $- $- $- $-
Donnie Joseph RP $- $- $- $-
Frank Francisco RP $- $- $- $-
Fernando Rodriguez RP $- $- $- $-
Kameron Loe RP $- $- $- $-
Mickey Storey RP $- $- $- $-
Collin McHugh RP $- $- $- $-
Cory Burns RP $- $- $- $-
Zach Duke RP $- $- $- $-
Curtis Partch RP $- $- $- $-
Chris Reed RP $- $- $- $-
Craig Breslow RP $- $- $- $-
Caleb Thielbar RP $- $- $- $-
Michael Blazek RP $- $- $- $-
Ryan Reid RP $- $- $- $-
Shawn Tolleson RP $- $- $- $-
Shaun Marcum SP $- $- $- $-
Preston Guilmet RP $- $- $- $-
Ian Krol RP $- $- $- $-
Alex Sanabia SP $- $- $- $-
Rob Rasmussen SP $- $- $- $-
John Lannan RP $- $- $- $-
Michael Mariot RP $- $- $- $-
James Russell RP $- $- $- $-
Jered Weaver SP $- $5.83 $- $-
Jose Cisnero RP $- $- $- $-
Shawn Camp RP $- $- $- $-
Matt Capps RP $- $- $- $-
Tom Koehler SP $- $- $- $-
Pedro Feliciano RP $- $- $- $-
Danny Rosenbaum SP $- $- $- $-
Brayan Villarreal RP $- $- $- $-
Juan Nicasio SP $- $- $- $-
Bobby LaFromboise RP $- $- $- $-
Rafael Dolis RP $- $- $- $-
Colt Hynes RP $- $- $- $-
Tyler Chatwood SP $- $- $- $-
Sean O’Sullivan RP $- $- $- $-
Josh Ravin RP $- $- $- $-
Andrew Albers SP $- $- $- $-
Robbie Ray SP $- $- $- $-
David Holmberg SP $- $- $- $-
Jon Rauch RP $- $- $- $-
Buddy Boshers RP $- $- $- $-
Ryan Brasier RP $- $- $- $-
Chad Durbin RP $- $- $- $-
Phillippe Aumont RP $- $- $- $-
Eddie Gamboa RP $- $- $- $-
Tim Byrdak RP $- $- $- $-
Francisley Bueno RP $- $- $- $-
Alex Wilson RP $- $- $- $-
Ryan Perry RP $- $- $- $-
Kyle Lobstein RP $- $- $- $-
Jeremy Horst RP $- $- $- $-
Kris Johnson RP $- $- $- $-
Phil Hughes SP $- $0.62 $- $-
Alex White SP $- $- $- $-
Felipe Rivero RP $- $- $- $-
Brad Hand SP $- $- $- $2.63
P.J. Walters RP $- $- $- $-
Kevin Munson RP $- $- $- $-
Chris Young SP $- $- $- $-
Logan Bawcom RP $- $- $- $-
Kelvin De La Cruz RP $- $- $- $-
Jose Arredondo RP $- $- $- $-
Greg Burke RP $- $- $- $-
Mike Montgomery RP $- $- $- $-
T.J. House RP $- $- $- $-
Kyle Kendrick SP $- $- $- $-
Daniel Bard RP $- $- $- $-
Henry Rodriguez RP $- $- $- $-
Shane Greene RP $- $- $- $-
David Martinez RP $- $- $- $-
Edgmer Escalona RP $- $- $- $-
Casey Coleman SP $- $- $- $-
Josh Lindblom SP $- $- $- $-
David Aardsma RP $- $- $- $-
Jeremy Bonderman RP $- $- $- $-
Kevin Gregg RP $- $- $- $-
Nik Turley RP $- $- $- $-
Matt Guerrier RP $- $- $- $-
Nick Maronde RP $- $- $- $-
Casey Crosby RP $- $- $- $-
A.J. Morris RP $- $- $- $-
Cesar Jimenez RP $- $- $- $-
Rudy Owens RP $- $- $- $-
Pedro Hernandez RP $- $- $- $-
Michael Stutes RP $- $- $- $-
Logan Darnell RP $- $- $- $-
Maikel Cleto RP $- $- $- $-
Cory Rasmus RP $- $- $- $-
Edgar Olmos RP $- $- $- $-
Brad Brach RP $- $- $- $-
Fernando Salas RP $- $- $- $-
Zach Miner RP $- $- $- $-
Michael Kirkman RP $- $- $- $-
Lucas Harrell SP $- $- $- $-
Kevin Shackelford RP $- $- $- $-
Jason Vargas SP $- $- $- $-
J.C. Ramirez RP $- $- $- $-
Dominic Leone RP $- $- $- $-
Brett Marshall RP $- $- $- $-
Jorge De Leon RP $- $- $- $-
Miles Mikolas RP $- $- $- $-
David Purcey RP $- $- $- $-
Michael Roth SP $- $- $- $-
Ryan Pressly RP $- $- $- $-
Steven Wright RP $- $- $- $-
Chris Rusin SP $- $- $- $-
Nick Christiani RP $- $- $- $-
Manny Banuelos RP $- $- $- $-
Zach McAllister SP $- $- $- $-
Robert Carson RP $- $- $- $-
Jake Petricka RP $- $- $- $-
Ramon Ramirez RP $- $- $- $-
Joe Saunders SP $- $- $- $-
Michael Belfiore RP $- $- $- $-
Jose Valdez RP $- $- $- $-
Wei-Yin Chen SP $- $1.50 $- $-
Donovan Hand RP $- $- $- $-
Mark Appel SP $- $- $- $-
Trey Haley RP $- $- $- $-
Daniel Corcino SP $- $- $- $-
Chris Dwyer SP $- $- $- $-
Rhiner Cruz RP $- $- $- $-
Luis Vasquez RP $- $- $- $-
Bronson Arroyo SP $- $- $- $-
Santos Rodriguez RP $- $- $- $-
Bud Norris SP $- $- $- $-
Mauricio Robles RP $- $- $- $-
Jose Ortega RP $- $- $- $-
Brad Peacock SP $- $- $- $-
Kevin Chapman RP $- $- $- $-
Jhoulys Chacin SP $- $- $- $-
Josh Stinson RP $- $- $- $-
Enny Romero RP $- $- $- $-
Frank De Los Santos RP $- $- $- $-
Mark Buehrle SP $- $- $- $-
Bruce Chen SP $- $- $- $-
Vance Worley SP $- $- $- $-
Edgar Ibarra RP $- $- $- $-
Chad Jenkins SP $- $- $- $-
Jacob Turner SP $- $- $- $-
Jake Westbrook SP $- $- $- $-
J.A. Happ SP $- $- $- $-
Deunte Heath RP $- $- $- $-
Greg Reynolds SP $- $- $- $-
Jorge de la Rosa SP $- $- $- $-
Martin Perez SP $- $- $- $-
Mike Pelfrey SP $- $- $- $-
John Lamb SP $- $- $- $-
Ethan Martin SP $- $- $- $-
Alexi Ogando SP $- $- $- $-
Travis Wood SP $- $- $- $-
Blake Beavan SP $- $- $- $-
Nestor Molina SP $- $- $- $-
Miguel Gonzalez SP $- $- $- $-
Scott Baker SP $- $- $- $-
Aaron Harang SP $- $- $- $-
Dylan Axelrod SP $- $- $- $-
Chris Narveson SP $- $- $- $-
Jeremy Guthrie SP $- $- $- $-
Daisuke Matsuzaka SP $- $- $- $-
Erik Johnson SP $- $- $- $-
John Danks SP $- $- $- $-
Tyler Cloyd SP $- $- $- $-
Brett Oberholtzer SP $- $- $- $-
Trevor Bauer SP $- $- $- $-
Johnny Hellweg SP $- $- $- $-
Paul Clemens SP $- $- $- $-
Jarred Cosart SP $- $- $- $-
Kevin Correia SP $- $- $- $-
Aaron Laffey SP $- $- $- $-
Andre Rienzo SP $- $- $- $-
Charlie Leesman SP $- $- $- $-
Barry Zito SP $- $- $- $-





A long-time fantasy baseball veteran and one of the creators of ottoneu, Chad Young's writes for RotoGraphs and PitcherList, and can be heard on the ottobot podcast. You can follow him on Twitter @chadyoung.

28 Responses to “Auction Values for All Four ottoneu Formats”

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.
  1. Clayton says:

    Chad, I used your formula discussed in series of articles from last year for a Fangraphs Points league (Points Against Replacement x (4500/39680)). My values are slightly different than yours based on Steamer projections. Care to discuss your formula and any updates?

    Also, I never really figured out where the 39680 number came from. Perhaps you could explain?

  2. Clayton says:

    Sorry, that’s Points *above replacement

  3. Chad Young says:
    FanGraphs Supporting Member

    Clayton, the denominator shouldn’t be 39,680, it should be the sum of all PAR for all players with PAR above 0.

    As for differences, the only real change was in how I projected holds, which I don’t have in front of me at the moment, but I will check it out later.

  4. Clayton says:

    Thanks for the clarification. You’ve been an extremely helpful resource.

  5. Chad Young says:
    FanGraphs Supporting Member

    Okay, holds – I used an equation that took into account appearances, K%, BB%, and Saves (because closers get very few holds, typically). I then ranked all RP by holds and more or less manipulated the holds counts to create a curve (from holds leader to guys with no holds) that matched roughly what we have seen in previous years. This is not terribly different from what I did last year, although I think it will work out a bit better.

    I’d keep in mind, though, with non-closing RP, holds are extremely volatile an, like saves, based on usage more than skill. These holds projections are really useful for making sure that RP as a whole are valued fairly, but it probably overvalues some while undervaluing others. RP are so volatile in general that trying to project auction values for them is probably something of a fool’s errand, but I am always game to be made a fool!

  6. smpeterson327 says:

    Why is Manny Machado worth nothing? Same with Yan Gomes… Im confused.

  7. Chad Young says:
    FanGraphs Supporting Member

    @smpetereson – don’t be confused!

    Re: Macahado, Steamer more or less projects him to repeat his 2013 and the dirty little secret about Machado is that, for fantasy purposes, he is a decidedly mediocre 3B. Machado was the #14 3B by wRC+ in 2013. By wOBA he was #12. Prefer comps? Machado’s 5×5 line: 14 HR, 6 SB, .283 AVG, 88 R, 71 RBI. Martin Prado’s: 14 HR, 3 SB, .282, 70, 82. Steamer has him 29th among 3B in wOBA in 2014. That might be extreme, but it is also telling. When he was a fantasy SS in ottoneu last year, he was a nice play, but unless the knee is totally healthy and he takes a big step forward, he is not an exciting play at 3B. If I owned Machado shares, I would be selling.

    Re: Gomes – His .342 BABIP last year greatly inflated his value and Steamer does not think that is sustainable. C is a deep position. Steamer sses him 17th by wOBA among C this year. He has potential, but he could also be a flop. I am buying on Gomes, as he has a history of higher-than-expected BABIPs and I am much higher than Steamer on his power potential. But that is why.

  8. Robert says:
    FanGraphs Supporting Member

    Where why is the comeback on Montero so optimistic? It’s less a question of (positive) regression than diminishing skills, isn’t it? It’s clear the rubric values power at the position, and maybe this is just a question of format but MM looked lost at the plate last year in simple terms of pitch recognition and plate discipline, and but his swing mechanics were horrifying. What gives?

  9. Chad Young says:
    FanGraphs Supporting Member

    @robert – assume you are talking Miguel? Steamer sees him between his great ’11/’12 output and his poor ’13 output, but it also sees him posting 600 PA. If he reaches that number, he not only gives you very solid C production (per Steamer), but also uses up an awful lot of the PA you would have given to a #2 C, since most other catchers project to 500 or fewer PA. Only 5 project for 600+ and they are the ones who project to play elsewhere often (Mauer, Santana, Castro, Posey) + Montero. Why Steamer expects this, I am not sure, but that is where the dollar figure comes from.

  10. schneidler says:
    FanGraphs Supporting Member

    Where is Jose Abreu?

  11. Chad Young says:
    FanGraphs Supporting Member

    @schneidler – no Steamer projection.

  12. Failedstate says:
    FanGraphs Supporting Member

    So no second year value like last year?

  13. Failedstate says:
    FanGraphs Supporting Member

    Sorry Apparently I don’t read good, disregard my last comment.

  14. Lee says:
    FanGraphs Supporting Member

    I understand ottoneau leagues are comprised of 12 teams with 40 man rosters. What is the auction budget for these teams? Is there a quick-and-dirty way to adjust these values to, for example, a 14 team league with a $260 budget and only 21 roster spots?

  15. Chad Young says:
    FanGraphs Supporting Member

    @lee – not really a good way to do that. You can review last year’s article (and the Zach Sanders articles linked to in that) and use the same approach, but just translating the values here is not the right path.

  16. Lee says:
    FanGraphs Supporting Member

    Thanks @Chad Young, I appreciate the guidance.

  17. Trey Baughn says:

    This won’t help with auction values, but here are a few more Ottoneu-specific tools if you’re preparing for your draft:
    http://www.fangraphs.com/community/ottoneu-tools-fgpoints/

  18. Teddy Wolvesevelt says:

    Was the formula for the Points format auction values still this one: PAR x 0.113 = auction value?

  19. difflja says:
    FanGraphs Supporting Member

    Hi Chad…..Thank you very much for all your good work here…..

    I am playing ottoneu for the first time this year, using FG points for scoring. Just checking: so the FG $value column is indexed to a $400 budget for a 40 man roster?

    Thank you again for your guidance……Jim D

  20. Chad Young says:
    FanGraphs Supporting Member

    @teddy – no, I followed the same process as last year but different projections means different multiplier. This year it was .132 Dollars/PAR.

    @difflja – yes.

  21. Teddy Wolvesevelt says:

    Thanks Chad!

  22. Chike says:
    FanGraphs Supporting Member

    I’m not sure how to interpret this chart. Based on my experiences playing 5×5 Ottoneu, these charts don’t pass the eyeball test. Especially at the top. What does that $33.09 value for Miguel Cabrera represent? Steamer projects him to put up more than $33 in value. Am I missing something here? This is based on a $400 Ottoneu budget, right?

  23. Chad Young says:
    FanGraphs Supporting Member

    @chike – nope, you are not. I screwed up. Fixed the values now, but somehow the process of taking them off the spreadsheet and into the article got messed up. Miggy is more like $47 in value. For what it’s worth, people tend to overvalue the top guys in 5×5 – the variety of categories that need to be filled make it nearly impossible for anyone to really stand out. Trout and Miggy are the only ones who really do. Tulo and Posey have great positional value, but you can’t dominate the way you can in pts leagues (or even 4×4) in 5×5.

  24. brian_msbc says:

    Just signed up for Fangraphs+, checked this article… the 5×5 auction values dont add up to $4800, they add up to $4062. Regardless of Auction stategy, the entire pool of players should add up to the total league money. Am i wrong???

  25. Chad Young says:
    FanGraphs Supporting Member

    Brian, first of all, remember that these a year old – feel free to use the methodology but the numbers themselves are out of date.

    Second the dollar figures leave money for teams to spend on things other than immediate production, mostly prospects, but also future projection. So someone like Marcus Stroman is $0 in the 5×5 projections because he did not project to create 2014 value (he did) but you some money was clearly going to be spent on him, based on future value.

  26. brian_msbc says:

    Chad, i agree that should be considered into the dollar value, but not by decreasing the total available cap. That doesn’t make sense. What i did in mine, is instead of decreasing the cap, I decreased the player pool. We can have a total of 40 players, 22 starters. Assuming you have one backup for every 2 starting slots (11), you should have a positive value for 33 players * 12 teams (399 players, call it 400). So, you should have 400 players (220 hitters, 180 pitchers) with positive values. The 401st player should have a negative value. All 400 players auction values should = $4800. That allows each owner to decide what do do with their extra roster space. Also, the 75, 20, 5 rule should be evident in the batter vs pitcher auction values. Meaning, if I sorted all players by auction value, I should see 75 batters, 20 SP’s, and 5 RP’s. Why are your pitching values half of what they should be? (I know these are a year old, I’m not talking specific players but overall).

  27. brian_msbc says:

    Maybe I can see your side of it, ottoneu auction values are tough because if the extra roster space, everyone would want a different auction value depending on whether you want to use that space for prospects, depth, or platoon players, or just open roster spots for waiver acquisitions. That’s why I just ignored the extra roster space in my spreadsheet.

  28. brian_msbc says:

    I meant 75 batters, 20 SP’s, 5 RP’s in the top 100.